Tuesday, March 26, 2019

March Madness Comes To La Politica; Udall Heads For Exits And Dems Start Filling In Their Brackets For The Big Game To Come; Frustrated R's Watch The Action From The Bench; Our Complete US Senate Coverage Is Up Next

March Madness came to La Politica in a big way Monday. Democratic US Senator Tom Udall, 70, announced he would not seek a third term in 2020, unleashing a flood of speculation over which Democrats are best positioned to replace him and leaving frustrated R's on the sidelines looking for a strong contender.

The announcement came as a mild surprise. Udall had made public statements indicating another run but there had also been speculation that he was ready to get out of DC. That started as far back as two years ago when he toyed with the idea of running for Governor.

Insiders say his health was not an issue and neither was that of his 80 year old wife Jill Udall who has had past health issues but ably presided over December's inauguration ceremonies for MLG.

They said that Udall simply did not want to spend the rest of his days in the Senate and wanted to do other things with his life. He said in his announcement that would include unspecified public service. He also said:

The worst thing anyone in public office can do is believe the office belongs to them, rather than to the people they represent.

Udall's announcement transcript here. Video here. NYT coverage here.

Udall's decision was reminiscent of the one made in 2011 by then 67 year old Senator Jeff Bingaman who decided not to seek another term in 2012. Like Udall he would have had a relatively easy re-election, but Bingaman had simply grown tired after 30 years on Capitol Hill. Udall has also been on the Hill 20 years and eight years as NM attorney general. He started in the US House in 1998.

In addition, the Republicans are poised to keep control of the Senate, not an appetizing prospect for the liberal Udall who hails from a storied political family out of Arizona and whose chief legacy will be his shepherding of environmental legislation and protections.

NO APPOINTMENT

Don't look for Udall to resign the seat and let Governor Lujan Grisham make the appointment to fill out the remainder of his term. He said Monday he will finish it out.

GAME ON

Now the guessing game is on as to who will emerge as the front-runner or front-runners for the highly coveted June 2020 US Senate nomination. After all, with the Republicans on the ropes the nomination could be tantamount to getting elected. The November election should be an easy lay up for the Dem primary victor.

CROWDED OR NOT?

Will it be a crowded free-for-all primary or one in which the field is quickly winnowed? Probably the latter because of the cost of a contested primary. One Dem political consultant pegs it at $3.5 million; another at $5 million if the race is really hot and heavy. Only a handful of candidates will be able to raise that amount of cash in the next year.

WHO IS THE FRONTRUNNER?

Balderas
Absent a list of any official candidates yet, the early front-runner for the Dem nomination right now is Attorney General Hector Balderas. That's because of his high name ID, his statewide wins for state auditor, as well as AG, and his previous race for the US Senate nomination in 2012 against Martin Heinrich.

His voting history shows a strong appeal to Hispanics. Some Hispanic groups are already clamoring on social media for one of their own to replace Udall.

In 2018 Balderas was the top vote getter statewide in the northern and ABQ congressional districts. Only Torres Small edged him in the southern district. There has not been a NM Hispanic US Senator since Joe Montoya ended his term in 1976 even though New Mexico is a majority-minority state.

Balderas reported over $600,000 in cash in his campaign account late last year. Under the law that money can't be spent directly on a federal race but it could be transferred to a PAC which could be run by a director friendly to Balderas. Also, he has been cultivating big name donors for his AG races and they could now be tapped for a Senate bid.

Expect Balderas to dive in soon. His statement:

Today’s focus is on Senator Udall and I’m grateful for his service as we continue to work together improving the lives of New Mexico children and families. After discussions with my wife and family, I will provide any updates at the appropriate time.

While being the very early front-runner has its advantages, it could also make Balderas a target of negative campaigning.

THE OTHERS

The others include Secretary of State Maggie Toulouse Oliver who has made no secret of her desire to serve in the Senate. Could she get the support of Emily's List and the big money it brings to a race? Will another prominent woman join the fray? Those are questions hovering over a potential candidacy.

Toulouse Oliver has a significant base in BernCo where she served as county clerk. Anglo Democratic women have been a major force in the Dem Party in the ABQ metro. If she could win the state's largest county she would be a statewide threat. However, some Dem analysts are already fretting that a race with Balderas and Toulouse Oliver as the top contenders could turn nasty and divisive with men vs. women, rural vs. city and all of it with a racial tinge.

(By the way, in a first test of Campaign '20 Balderas came with a news release praising the outgoing Udall at 12:45 p.m. and Toulouse Oliver hit the wires at 1:05 p.m. Can Maggie catch up? :)

OUR DC TRIO

Rep. Lujan 
New Mexico's three Dem congressional representatives--Deb Haaland, Xochitl Torres Small from the south and Rep. Ben Ray Lujan from the north are all mentioned as possible candidates. But Haaland and Torres Small only began their first House terms a couple of months ago. It may be too soon for either of them. The betting line is they stay put but that same line had Udall probably running. Haaland could be an intriguing candidate. A Native American female US senator would be another first for her, the state and nation.

A DC Senior Alligator says of Rep. Torres Small, 34, a former aide to Udall:

There will be enormous pressure for her to take the southern seat into 2021 redistricting and not leave it to run for Senate. The Dems could make the seat their own with the new lines to be drawn then. If an R were to take it back, that task becomes more difficult. 

And then there is the liberal wing of the party that is upset with Torres Small's middle of the road approach.

Lujan is now Assistant Speaker and one of the most powerful congressional reps in DC. Does he want to give up a possible shot at some day becoming Speaker of the House for a Senate desk?

It's alluring for him because of all the candidates for the Dem nod being mentioned he is the only one with the ability to clear the field. He has new national political power and a strong home base. If Lujan were to make the run the race would be pretty much decided.

Here's his statement regarding a Senate run:

I am humbled by the outpouring of support I received today. In the weeks to come, I will speak with my family, New Mexicans, and supporters about the opportunity to serve our state in the U.S. Senate.

Right about now Balderas is having heart palpitations because if Ben Ray jumps in the pool, Hector drowns. And Haaland stays out.

If Lujan takes a pass the question becomes who he would like to see in the seat. You could easily see him collaborating on the matter with Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer. Remember it was Schumer who in 2008 recruited Udall for the Senate race to replace Republican Pete Domenici. Under that pressure former ABQ Mayor Marty Chavez withdrew his candidacy.

Here's something to watch. New Mexican Dan Sena rose to national prominence as a political consultant under Lujan when he was chairman of the Dem Congressional Campaign Committee. He has now opened his own consulting firm. If Sena signs with Balderas. . . well, you get the picture.

TIM STAYS

ABQ Mayor Tim Keller, 41, has also been mentioned as a possible hopeful, but his office ruled out a run  Monday, saying he is staying  put. It is expected he will seek re-election as Mayor in 2021. He has never had a hankering to serve in DC.

SECOND TIER

There will be a gaggle of others looking at the Dem nomination wondering if lightning might strike. They would include Lt. Governor Howie Morales, ABQ businessman Jeff Apodaca, who ran for the Dem nod for Governor last year; also Dem State Senators Jeff Steinborn, Jacob Candelaria, Joe Cervantes and Pete Campos will give it a look.

Former NM USDA Regional Director Terry Brunner is also pondering. House Speaker Brian Egolf will be tempted. All of them except Morales, Brunner and Apodaca would have to give up their current positions to make the run so keep your bets to yourself.

THE REPUBLICANS

Sanchez and Martinez
While the Dems have a deep potential bench for the Senate game, the R's are having difficulty suiting up. Former Lt. Governor John Sanchez, 56, is their top pick but would he make a run knowing a loss would mean his chances of ever taking the governorship could be over? And then there is the baggage he carries from Gov. Susana Martinez. That's a heavy load indeed.

Martinez would have been a natural for the Senate run but she left office deeply unpopular and amid a scandal hanging over her head involving her state police bodyguard who collected a large settlement from the state. And that's just for starters.

Digging deeper for some viable names we surfaced former House Minority Leader Nate Gentry, former ABQ GOP State Rep. Sarah Maestas Barnes and current Valencia County State Rep. Kelly Fajardo.

None of them are seen as likely candidates because of the financial challenge but each has political acumen that sets them apart from the GOP crowd, analyzed veteran Dem consultant James Hallinan. 

Fear was expressed by some Republicans that current GOP state chairman Steve Pearce, fresh off a landslide loss in the ‘18  race for governor, would run. His 2008 candidacy against Sen. Udall ended with him getting whipped in another landslide.

The rest of the names that GOP insiders floated are relative unknowns. They include ABQ businessmen Doug Turner who ran for the Guv nod in 2010; Mick Rich who suffered a landslide loss last year to Dem US Senator Heinrich and Steve Maestas, an ABQ real estate developer who is married to former NM GOP Chair Deborah Weh.

The national R's are not expected to target the race after the way the state went deep blue last year. They have too many other contests to babysit that will insure their continued grip on the Senate. Local R's will likely be left to their own devices, and that reveals how precious that Dem US Senate nomination will be for the lucky winner.

REACTION ROW

Here's a sample of reaction from across the state to Udall's announcement that he's packing it in:

Marg Elliston, chair of the NM Dem Party: He’s a trailblazer on environmental protection, helps grow vital military and research installations throughout the state, fights to improve rural healthcare access, defends tribal sovereignty, and puts his fellow New Mexicans first.

Steve Pearce, chair of the NM GOP: Given the Democrats progressive trend, they will likely nominate someone who is far too liberal to represent New Mexico. . . I can unequivocally state that our candidate will provide a clear contrast with anyone whom the Democrats recruit to run.

Gov. MLG--Whether serving the people of this state as attorney general, as a congressman, as a senator or simply as a neighbor and friend, Tom Udall has reliably put New Mexicans first. He has fought for our water, for our lands, for our people, and his voice has been a consistent beacon of leadership and moral clarity in turbulent times

Mike Johnson of Santa  Fe on social media: So glad to see this incompetent, elite, fortunate son go. Good riddance. So many Viet Nam vets will be very happy.

Ray Gray on Facebook: Best news all day! Now if we could just get him to take Martin with him! Enjoy that hefty retirement from us taxpayers!

Jon Hendry on Facebook: Udall's been quietly effective without the grandstanding. NM is about to have little seniority on important committees which is tough when we rely on the Feds.

This is the home of New Mexico politics.

E-mail your news and comments. (jmonahan@ix.netcom.com)

Interested in reaching New Mexico's most informed audience? Advertise here. 

(c)NM POLITICS WITH JOE MONAHAN 2019